Table 4 is a summary
of a Caltrans sponsored testing by Woodward Clyde of commonly used BMPs.
The effectiveness is measured by the % reduction in sediment loss from standardized
test bed trials done at San Diego State University. We have provided links
to the products available from S&S Seeds under the BMP heading.
Table 4
EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL BMPs
INSTALLED COSTS AND EFFECTIVENESS
| BMP |
Unit Cost Installed |
Estimated Relative
Erosion/
Sediment Control Effectiveness |
| Sediment
Control |
| Silt Fence |
$1.50 - 2.00 per lineal
foot |
UNK |
| Fiber Rolls (9 inch)
ssseeds.com/ecb/product_sid.html
(12 inch) |
$1.50 - 2.00 per lineal
foot
$2.00 - 2.50 per lineal foot |
58%
95% |
| Erosion
Control |
| Fertilizer
ssseeds.com/other_products.html |
$450 - 550 per acre |
N/A |
| Seeding
ssseeds.com/reclamation_mixes.html |
$870 - 2,170 per acre |
50% |
| Stolonizing |
$2,200 per acre + cost
of stolons |
90% |
| Hydraulic Mulching (2,000
lbs/acre)
ssseeds.com/other_products.html |
$900 - 1,200 per acre |
50 - 60% |
| Compost Application (2,000lbs/acre
ssseeds.com/other_products_hydropost.html |
$900 - 1,200 per acre |
40 - 50% |
| Straw Mulching |
$1,800 - 2,100 per acre |
90 - 95% |
| Soil Binders |
|
|
| Plant
Material-Based (Short-Term)
ssseeds.com/other_products_guar.html
|
$700 - 900 per acre |
80 - 85% |
| Plant
Material-Based (Long-Term)
ssseeds.com/other_products_mbinder.html
|
$1,200 - 1,500 per acre |
60 - 65% |
| Polymeric
Emulsion Blends
ssseeds.com/other_products_dss40.html
ssseeds.com/other_products_earthg.html
ssseeds.com/other_products_ultrat.html
|
$700 - 1,500 per acre |
30 - 95% |
| Petroleum
Resin-Based
|
$1,200 - 1,500 per acre |
25 - 20% |
| Cementitious
Binder-Based (4,500 lbs/ac)
|
$800 - 1,200 per acre |
80 - 85% |
| Bonded Fiber Matrices (3,500
lbs/ac)
ssseeds.com/other_products.html
ssseeds.com/other_products.html |
$5,000 - 6,500 per acre |
90 - 95% |
| Rolled Erosion Control
Products |
|
|
| Biodegradable
|
|
|
|  Jute
|
$6,000 - 7,000 per acre |
65 - 70% |
|  Curled
Wood Fiber
|
$8,000 - 10,500 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Straw
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_ws05.html
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_ws072.html
|
$8,000 - 10,500 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Wood
Fiber
|
$8,000 - 10,500 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Coconut
Fiber
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_cf072rr.html
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_cf072b.html
|
$13,000 - 14,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Coconut
Fiber Net
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_cfg2000.html
|
$30,000 - 33,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Straw
Coconut
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_cfs072r.html
 ssseeds.com/ecb/product_cfs072b.html
|
$10,000 - 12,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
| Non-Biodegradable
|
|
|
|  Plastic
Netting
|
$2,000 - 2,200 per acre |
< 50% |
|  Plastic
Mesh
 greenfix.com/html/frame_greenspec.htm
|
$3,000 - 3,500 per acre |
75 - 80% |
|  Synthetic
Fiber w/Netting
|
$34,000 - 40,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Bonded
Synthetic Fibers
|
$45,000 - 55,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
|  Combination
Synthetic and Biodegradable Fibers
|
$30,000 - 36,000 per acre |
90 - 95% |
| Source: Erosion Control Pilot
Study Report,
URS Greiner Woodward Clyde, June 2000, Table 4-1, Revised May
26, 2003 |
|
|
Seed Mixes: Wildflowers | Turfgrasses
| Reclamation / Erosion
Other
Products | New! Erosion Control Blankets
Plant
Database | BMPs - Cost vs. Benefit
| Inventory | Request
Information
About S&S Seeds, Inc. | S&S
Services | Newsletter | Contact
Us | Home
Retail
Sales/Small Orders
|
|
S&S
Seeds, Inc.
P.O. Box 1275
Carpinteria, CA 93014-1275
(805) 684-0436
(805) 684-2798 fax
|
|
|
|
© 1998-2007 by S&S Seeds.
All Rights Reserved. Text, graphics, and HTML code are protected
by US and International Copyright Laws, and may not be copied, reprinted,
published, translated, hosted, or otherwise distributed by any means
without explicit permission
Web Developer: CogniText.
|
|